It doesn’t often happen that one finds an unexpected
jewel of a film. It’s like striking gold
in a coal mine.
Yesterday, I found such a jewel at the Tribeca Film
Festival. It’s a film by Israeli
Writer/Director Hargar Ben-Asher entitled Dead Women Walking.
The film deals with 8 women, who are within days, some within
hours, of being put to death for their crimes.
Sounds gruesome, right? Actually,
more heartrending.
I must admit that, at first, I thought I was watching a real-life
documentary and it was only until the second or third segment that, because of the
excellent cinematographic style of David Stragmeister, I realized no documentarian
could have captured the images of these women so closely and beautifully.
But, that was also a testament to the brilliant performances
of every single actor in this film, from the eight women to their families and
the prison staffs at the various institutions.
Kudos to Casting Director Rich Delia.
The viewer can’t help but form an initial judgment of
each woman as to whether she would deserve such a harsh punishment and the first
three come across as sympathetic in various degrees. It was only the fourth, being driven from the
prison to the death house, who seemed like someone you would never want to
meet. She even claimed she had no heart.
But, as she entered the death house, we discovered she had more heart
than the men who drove her there.
And, it’s at this point, you realize the brilliance of
Ben-Asher’s writing, which only gets better from there to the eighth story,
which made a perfect ending to the film.
The only debatable “flaw” to this masterpiece was the
ninth segment that I felt overstated the film’s point. But, it by no means ruined the experience.
While we know the crimes of these women were heinous, the
film makes one consider whether death as opposed to rehabilitation would be
more beneficial to society as a whole…whether the quality of mercy should
triumph over vengeance.
Whichever viewpoint you have at the start of this film, it
is worth your going through the challenge Dead Women Walking offers. I give the film 4.6 out of 5 and hope that a
courageous distributor will get it into theaters so that you can have this
worthwhile cinematic thrill.